Experiences With Social Identity Threat: Investigating Threat’s Impact on the Self
AuthorHoushang Tehrani, Estera
MetadataShow full item record
AbstractHow does social identity threat impact a person's thoughts and feelings about their self? We predicted that an identity under threat may dominate the individual’s self-concept and be viewed less positively in the moment. In two studies, we collected self-reported past experiences of social identity threat, along with ratings of the salience, positivity, centrality, and subjective concealability of participants’ multiple social identities. In Study 1 (N = 211), we found that the identity targeted by threat increased in salience, while the non-threatened identities tended to shrink away slightly. In Study 2 (N = 183), using social identity mapping methods, we did not find an increase in the threatened identity’s salience, but as in Study 1, the non-threatened identities decreased in salience during threat. Across both studies, we found a decrease in positive feelings toward the threatened social identity, which predicted a more negative emotional state during threat. Effects of identity centrality and subjective concealability were weak and inconsistent between the two studies. These results provide partial evidence that social identity threat experiences momentarily influence the cognitive and emotional components of social identity. Implications for impacts of long-term chronic exposure to social identity threat on the self are discussed.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
English Language Learners, Writing Challenges, and Writing Identities: Experiences of Graduate Student Writers in EducationFarzinpur, LeilaThis qualitative research, grounded within a sociocultural perspective, investigated the experiences of non-native speakers of English when they write in an academic context in graduate level education courses. I explored writing challenges and success, the effects of challenges on writing identity, and strategies and environment that enhance writing competency of 3 English Language Learners (ELLs) in an Ontario University. Data were collected through a survey design including a questionnaire, semi-structured interviews, and post-interview questions. Data analysis adopted a 6-step process for analyzing and interpreting qualitative data described by Creswell (2015). The study’s theoretical framework encompassed Ivanič’s (2004) multilayered view of language, and Ivanič’s (1998) 4 aspects of writing identities. Findings suggest that ELLs’ academic literacy practices are influenced by various elements, their writing identities are constructed and shifted in the academic setting, and their writing challenges have a significant influence on different aspects of their writing identities. In addition, ELLs can improve their writing competency and make progress in their academic literacy if they are provided with an appropriate and supportive learning environment, practices, and strategies. The study discusses implications of findings and suggests areas for further research.
Using Self-Compassion and Teacher Identity to Examine the Transition from Teacher to Teacher EducatorBriggs, Spencer; Applied Health Sciences ProgramThere has been considerable research regarding teacher identity and the challenges involved with the transition from teacher to teacher educator, yet there is little existing literature that addresses how to manage or mitigate these challenges. In my research, I describe the influences on my identification process and use the concept of self-compassion as a tool to support the transition from teacher to teacher educator. Self-compassion “involves offering nonjudgmental understanding to one’s pain, inadequacies and failures, so that one’s experience is seen as part of the larger human experience” (Neff, 2003b, p. 87). Data gathering and analysis were informed by self-study methodology and consisted of personal reflections and conversations with a critical friend. From the ensuing analysis, I developed three themes. First, the challenges I faced included differentiating pedagogy, returning to academia, and my perspectives of others’ perceptions. Each of these factors influenced my identification process during my transition. Second, through conversations with a critical friend, we came to see my product over process mindset, which prompted a new way of conceptualizing and acting upon these challenges. Lastly, supportive others and engaging with self-study provided a means to better understand how I practiced self-compassion and shift my mindset about challenges in new ways. Implications for this research may resonate with others who undergo similar transitions; the findings may also be informative to others making personal and professional transitions in a broader context.
Dear SSHRC, What Do You Want? An Epistolary Narrative of Expertise, Identity, and Time in Grant WritingMcGinn, Michelle K.; Acker, Sandra; Vander Kloet, Marie; Wagner, Anne (Institut für Qualitative Forschung, 2019)The current research climate has heightened expectations for social science researchers to secure research grant funding at the same time that such funding appears to be more competitive than ever. As a result, researchers experience anxiety, confusion, loss of confidence, second guessing, and a lack of trust in the system and themselves. This autoethnographic study provides an insider perspective on the intellectual, emotional, and physical experience of grant writing. A team of scholars document the production of a research grant for their major national funding agency, the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. The story is presented through epistolary narrative in the form of a series of unsent letters addressed to the funding agency. The letters foreground themes of expertise, identity, and time as they were shaped through the grant-writing process. The analysis draws attention to unnecessary complexities and challenges that could and should be eliminated from granting processes if the intention is to foster quality research and strengthen research capacity. Implications may prove instructive for other grant applicants, resource personnel employed to support applicants, and potential funders.