Social Justice and Equity Studies MRP
Browse by
Students currently enrolled in the Social Justice and Equity Studies graduate program here at Brock University will be required to submit an electronic copy of their final Major Research Paper to this repository as part of graduation requirements.
If you are logged in please click on 'Submit a New Item to this Collection' to proceed.
Once your MRP has been accepted in the Repository you will receive an email confirmation along with a link to your workRecent Submissions
-
Inclusive Education in Ghana: Challenges and Lessons from CanadaThis Major Research Paper (MRP) adopted the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) approach to examine the evolution and current state of inclusive education in Ghana and Canada (Ontario), with an emphasis on challenges and lessons learned. The movement towards inclusive education began in Ghana in 1936, with separate schools for disabled children. However, challenges remain, such as geographic disparities, prohibitive costs, and a lack of teacher understanding. Inclusive education has evolved over the last 50 years in Canada, thanks to legislative advancements such as the 1982 Charter of Rights and Freedoms and provincial acts. Key findings show that Ontario is significantly ahead of the curve when it comes to implementing inclusive education, thanks to diverse provincial approaches and effective strategies. Despite challenges in both countries, Canada's lack of a unified national policy contrasts with Ghana's policy, which is riddled with problems, limiting its effectiveness. Discrimination against disabled children is less prevalent in Ontario than in Ghana, where negative attitudes prevent inclusion. Financial constraints are a common barrier, with Ontario’s lessons pointing to a comprehensive framework that combines Universal Design for Learning and Differentiated Instruction to address financial concerns while also improving inclusive practices. Challenges for teachers and principals in both systems highlight the importance of teacher preparation and school leadership in implementing successful inclusive education policies. Lessons from Ontario focus on strategies for incorporating inclusive education principles into teacher training programs and increasing principal accountability, emphasizing the importance of professional development and leadership in fostering inclusive practices. Drawing lessons from Ontario, the findings highlight the need for a comprehensive national policy in Ghana that addresses financial constraints while promoting teacher and principal preparation to improve inclusive education outcomes.
-
Picture this: Representing Local Discourses of Poverty Reduction through Graphic NotetakingPoverty researchers, and in turn the poverty reduction practitioners they inform, often fail to conceptualize poverty as structural, evolving, systematic, complex and above all, political (Harriss 2012). A key aspect of this failure is the tendency to define and measure poverty in primarily economistic terms (Yapa 1996). Objective, economistic constructions of poverty are often depoliticized, as Elwood and Lawson (2018) assert, “to stabilize political-economic orders and power hierarchies” (p. 2). Understandings of poverty that fail to acknowledge its social and political dimensions can lead researchers to focus on questions such as “Why are poor people poor?” (Yapa, 1996). Such questions reinscribe poverty as a normal part of the social order and localize conversations of poverty to the individual. To avoid taking poverty for granted, we need to ask why specific groups of people in specific times, locations, and contexts are experiencing hunger, houselessness, lack of safety, mobility, health care, and barriers to participation in social life. We also need to ask the concomitant question, why do specific groups of people in particular times, locations, and contexts have differential access to material wealth, political legibility, and social value? Taking such a political approach, my research examines discourses of poverty within a local context. Additionally, I examine how engaging in these discourses visually, through the drawing of graphic notes, offers a way to excavate and explore some of the shortcomings and possibilities of poverty politics in Niagara. My research involves drawing a series of graphic notes for ten community consultations organized by the Niagara regional government which aimed to gather community input to inform the region’s process of writing a poverty reduction strategy.
-
Bolivia and Canada, The Politics of Recognition and Differing Approaches to Indigenous Self-DeterminationThis project asks; to what extent has the Bolivian approach to Indigenous self-government demonstrated an effective policy framework that could be applicable in the Canadian context? This is accomplished through an application of a comprehensive theoretical framework to the analysis of the Canadian and Bolivian approaches to Indigenous self-determination. Several important themes are analyzed including the two Constitutions, political discourse, the historicization of colonialism, the importance of land, and the significance of the Leftist movement. This analysis leads to the realization that Bolivia has proven that the plurinational state is a feasible solution to the colonial homogenous conception of sovereignty. The lessons learned from the Bolivian states approach to Indigenous self-determination can inform decolonial options for the Canadian state.
-
Bias, Barriers, and Discrimination: Treatment of Indigenous Peoples in Wellness CourtsMajor Research Paper (MRP) focused on Indigenous knowledge systems compared to Wellness Courts, engaging a critical literature review that integrates insights from professional practice experiences as a Registered Social Worker. As a result, reflexivity was used as a key method in the research and facilitated an in-depth analysis of current literature. This MRP is positioned to contribute to understanding the impact of Wellness Courts concerning the needs and goals of Indigenous communities.
-
Education as Reconciliation?: Unpacking the Relationship between Non-Indigenous Canadian/Indigenous Reconciliation and Ontario Secondary School Canadian History TextbooksAt the present moment, Canada is at a crossroads. Canada claims to be promoting the restoration of non-Indigenous Canadian/Indigenous relations in an effort to heal from the trauma of its settler colonial past (while limiting recognition of the present consequences of this history). This project, guided by a decolonizing framework, conducts a content analysis of four Canadian history textbooks published for Ontario high schools from 2000-2014 and the associated Canadian history curriculum guidelines for grades nine/ten and eleven/twelve students from 2000-2018. I ask if these history textbooks supported by the Ontario Ministry of Education facilitate students to be interested in reconciliation efforts, particularly looking the attitudes towards Indigenous peoples and the ways various settler colonial events are explained. This research has shown that the Canadian history textbooks used in conjunction with these curricula act as both an encouragement and discouragement to reconciliation through both the content that is taught (or not) and the language used surroundings the subjects covered. As these textbooks and curricula evolve and reflect more of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada’s Calls to Action, particularly Calls 62-65, there appears to be greater opportunities for students to discuss Indigenous issues, their roles in these issues, and ultimately, their roles and responsibilities in reconciliation.
-
Raising the Bar and Closing the Gap? Investigating Learning for All’s Capacity to Support Marginalized Students in OntarioLearning for All (2013) is a resource guide, published by Ontario’s Ministry of Education, that aims to “raise the bar and close the gap in achievement for all students” (p. 3). It is intended to be used by school boards to support system-level planning and informs professional development and local policy directives (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2013). Learning for All does acknowledge that outcome disparities are more prevalent between certain demographic groups, but it avoids any discussion of the complex factors that cause this inequity. This paper explores the research on economically and racially marginalized students in Canada, to reveal the institutional, pedagogical, and ideological factors that produce this education inequity. From this research informed position, I offer a critical policy analysis of Learning for All guided by Paul Gorksi & Katy Swalwell’s Equity Literacy Framework (2015), which demonstrates that the strategies prescribed in Learning for All will not only fail to ‘close the gap’ but may also rein-force deficit thinking amongst educators, thereby exacerbating the problem. Finally, this paper concludes with recommended structural and pedagogical changes, as well as opportunities for future research to better address the barriers that marginalized students face and the shortcomings of Learning for All.
-
Working Conditions of Front-Line Poverty-Reduction Staff at Non-profit AgenciesOver the past three to four decades in Ontario, neoliberalization and new public management have restructured the non-profit social services (NPSS) sector by reducing core funding and introducing a competitive proposal system with increased managerial accountability. These changes have generated immense workplace pressures for frontline staff. Frontline staff in the NPSS have seen an increase in standardization accompanied by the degradation of their skills. Through in-depth interviews with five frontline staff at two similar non-profit agencies serving people experiencing poverty in the Niagara Region, this paper explores the question: How do frontline staff in the non-profit social services sector describe their working conditions? And how resonant are the narratives of compassion fatigue and burnout. In contrast to the narrative of "compassion fatigue" that often describes the experiences of professional frontline workers, I found that burnout among frontline poverty-reduction staff stems primarily from encountering structural barriers, such as a lack of affordable housing, that limit what they can do to help their service users. Furthermore, I found a general lack of organizational supports for frontline staff as workers, including supports to prevent or lessen burnout. This research brings to light new perspectives regarding poverty-reduction work and ultimately points to needed supports for frontline staff that may improve their work lives, well-being and poverty-reduction effectiveness.
-
The Construction of Racialized Criminality in Film: A Critical Analysis of The Shawshank Redemption (1994) and Just Mercy (2019)The focus of this research is to examine the ways in which media representations of racialized criminality affect the public’s perceptions of race and its connection to criminality, authority and punishment. This is done methodologically through the deep critical analysis of the films The Shawshank Redemption (1994) and Just Mercy (2019). Many forms of media are readily and constantly available to the public, for some more than others based on a number of intersecting social factors. Because of its prevalence, the media and the stories they tell are important to analyze and should not be ignored. The films The Shawshank Redemption (1994) and Just Mercy (2019) were chosen for their depiction of racialized characters in and related to the context of the prison. In addition, the passage of time between their release dates allows for a thorough investigation of possible evolution of these representations. It is imperative that this research be approached from an intersectional point of view, allowing it to accurately expose the ways in which oppression, as it relates to race, may or may not be present in the films and affect the public’s perceptions of racialized criminality. These films represent people of colour and their interactions with white people, in positions of power and submission in each film. As well, there are intersections of race, gender, and sexuality as they relate to criminality, authority and punishment.
-
The Social Construction of the DSM-5 & its Impact on Patient DignityThe Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorder (5th Ed. or DSM-5) represents a foundational text within the psychiatric and mental health field, a document that is historically and socially positioned within the field as the global standard for diagnostic health information. Significant criticism, though, has been levelled against the DSM-5, highlighting concerns around its underlying ethnocentric positioning as well as scientific concerns around the reliability and validity of different diagnoses. This study explores the current state of the DSM-5. It seeks to understand how its development has shaped and promoted a variety of discourses within the mental health field, as well as looking at the impact these discourses have had on the dignity and day-to-day functioning of millions of patients, both younger and elder, for whom it has been conceived to offer therapeutic interventions. Drawing on Social Constructionist and Foucauldian frameworks to conduct this discursive analysis of the DSM-5, I identify the dominant discourses of the DSM-5, as well as the discursive rules which have been reinforced by the American Psychiatric Association to promote these practices. The dominant discourses identified include expertise, medicalizing normality, conceptualizations of culture, and control.